ABOVE-GROUND WINTER COVERS · LEARNING WITH THE FIN
A winter cover is not a safety cover. Especially the one on your above-ground pool.
Most of the pools we sell at The Fin are above-ground, so this is the big class on the cover that actually goes on those pools. How to size it, cable and winch, clips, wall bags, the air pillow, solid versus mesh, how to get the water and leaves off, and how to take it off in the spring without turning it into a science experiment.
A regular winter cover is great at keeping debris out of the water. It is not a safety device. We’ll still give safety covers a clear, shorter word later, because those two names are not cousins. Every fact on this page comes from official standards, CPSC guidance, or manufacturer instructions. If they didn’t print it, we didn’t either.
By Ryan Musch
Director of Liquid Affairs, The Fin
POOL SCHOOL · COVER EDITION
What this story covers. Above-ground winter covers are the main event — sizing, install, care, and spring storage for the pools The Fin sells and services in Tulsa, plus a short word on semi-in-ground and smaller in-ground setups. Safety covers get their own, shorter section. No prices, and no “we carry Brand X” claims. Your cover’s own instructions and your local codes always win. This sits alongside Pool School’s winterizing guide, which is the bedtime routine for the whole pool. This one is about the blanket.
“A winter cover is a raincoat for your pool. A safety cover is a seatbelt. Please do not confuse the two.”
— Ryan Musch, The Fin · authored for this page
HOW TO SIZE AN ABOVE-GROUND WINTER COVER
Bigger than the pool. Not a wild guess.
You do not order a cover by squinting at the box and hoping the number matches the water. You order it by the size and shape of the pool. The cover itself is cut larger than the pool so it can drape over the top rail and still rest on the water once the level is down.
ROUND
One number, through the middle.
Measure rail to rail, straight across the center. That’s your diameter. Use a round cover on a round pool, and order the size that matches your pool on the maker’s chart — for example, a 24-foot pool gets the cover the chart lists for a 24-foot pool, even though the fabric you unfold will measure larger than 24 feet.
OVAL
Width and length, at their widest.
Measure the width and the length at the widest points, rail to rail. Use an oval cover on an oval pool. A round cover will not magically become an oval because you tug on it, and stretching a cover to make it “fit” is how you tear one. Order the oval size the chart lists for your pool.
Follow the maker’s sizing chart. How much larger the cover is than the pool is not a universal number. Some makers add a couple of feet, some add more. That’s why the package often shows two numbers: the pool size you order by, and the actual cover size you receive. Wide top rails eat into that overhang; some makers say if your rails are on the wide side, you may need the next size up. If you’re between sizes, go to the chart’s next size up, or bring the measurements in and we’ll look at it with you. A cover that’s too small gets stretched, and a stretched cover is a sad cover.
An air pillow — cover makers also call it an ice equalizer — goes in the center of an above-ground pool, under the cover. It absorbs ice expansion so the walls aren’t taking all that pressure, and it keeps the cover from sagging into a heavy puddle of snow and leaves in the middle. It is not a toy and not a life preserver. Keep it away from children.
SIZING
Match the pillow to the pool.
Use the maker’s pillow chart, not vibes. Bigger pools need a bigger pillow, or more than one. Charts typically step up through a few standard sizes as the pool gets larger, and some cover makers would rather see a couple of smaller pillows than one giant one — if one fails, the others still help. Odd-shaped or larger ovals are often in the “more than one” column.
INFLATION
About two-thirds. Not drum-tight.
Inflate it only partway — official instructions say about half to three-quarters, or 60 to 70 percent, which is about two-thirds of the way. Do not fill it all the way. It needs room inside to take the squeeze when ice expands. A stuffed pillow is a pillow looking for a way to fail.
PLACEMENT
Center stage, and it stays there.
Park it in the middle of the pool. Tie the ropes through the pillow’s grommets to the side walls or top rails so it stays put, but not so tight that the lines can’t move. The pillow still needs to float up and down on the water. Ropes yanked tight are how grommets tear and pillows wander off.
THEN THE COVER
Hug the pillow. Rest on the water.
Drape the cover over the pillow and onto the water around it. The cover should embrace the pillow and still sit on the water, not hover in a tight tent or get stretched flat. If a pillow fails midwinter, that’s a “too much stress on the cover” moment: pump the water off the top and fix the pillow situation before the cover pays for it.
CABLE, WINCH, CLIPS, AND BAGS
Tuck it in. Tight. Wind is not a fastener.
How well a winter cover works depends on how well it’s fastened down. A lot of good covers die young because of a sloppy install, and wind getting underneath is usually the weapon.
The cable-and-winch close
Close the pool first. Clean, balanced, winterized — that’s the other Pool School guide. Take out ladders and anything else in the water. Anything you still need to do in the water is a lot harder after the cover is on.
Set the water where the instructions say — and do not drain the pool to “hold” the cover. The cover is supposed to rest on the water. That’s what supports it. Lower the water only as the pool and cover makers say: often just below the skimmer, unless you’re using a skimmer cover plate and the instructions say you can leave it up. Some cover makers also set a minimum water level under the cover, because a cover that’s hanging in midair gets stretched and torn. Don’t empty the pool for the winter, and don’t drop it to a puddle to try to make the cover stay put.
Pad the sharp stuff. Top-rail caps, fences, deck corners, and the underside of the winch all chew covers for a living. Tape or foam now is cheaper than a rip in February.
Pillow in, then the cover. Centered, tied, inflated partway. If the cover has a dark side, the label usually wants that side down, toward the water. Pull it on evenly — two people, cover folded in half and walked out, is the usual dance — so the overhang is even around the wall and the cover hugs the pillow, then rests on the water. It should come up the side wall and meet the water, not get stretched into a drum skin.
Lace the cable through every grommet. Feed both ends into the winch (or ratchet), pull until it’s reasonably taut, then turn the handle until the cable is snug under the top rails and wind can’t sneak underneath. If the fabric bunches, walk it out and straighten it, then finish tightening. Check that tension now and then through the winter.
Clips and bags are helpers, not the whole plan. They work with the cable, not instead of it.
COVER CLIPS
Clothespins, but for your top rail.
Clips clamp the cover to the outside of the top rail so it stays taut and doesn’t whip in the wind. They’re meant to go on with the cable-and-winch system already tight. Makers typically want them on both sides of each upright, and more of them in a windy yard. Follow the clip maker, and don’t skip the cable because the clips looked confident.
WALL BAGS AND WATER TUBES
Weight, without the milk jugs.
Wall bags sit on top of the cover around the inside perimeter and usually clip to the cable by their grommets. Thread them on empty, tighten the cable, then fill them about half to three-quarters of the way so ice has room to expand. If you have a walk-around deck, winter-cover instructions often call for water tubes on the deck — end to end, with no inviting gaps — or a mix of tubes and clips on a partial deck. Do not use milk jugs, bricks, boards, or anything sharp hung from the grommets. That’s a classic way to ruin a cover, and some warranties say so out loud.
SOLID VS. MESH · ABOVE-GROUND WINTER COVERS
Same job. Different fabric.
Above-ground winter covers come in solid and mesh. Both are still winter covers. Neither one becomes a safety cover because of the weave.
SOLID
The blackout curtain.
A solid cover keeps debris and sunlight out of the pool. No sunlight means a lot less algae, and rain that stays on top isn’t diluting the water underneath. The trade-off is that rain and snowmelt collect on top, so you need a cover pump (or a siphon) to get that water off. A lake on a solid cover is heavy, it’s messy if it finds a way in, and standing water on a cover is a hazard in its own right.
MESH
The drain-through.
A mesh winter cover is an open weave: leaves and larger debris stay on top, and water drains through to the pool. You typically don’t have a lake to pump off. Ultra-fine dust and silt can sneak through, so you may see a little sediment on the floor at opening, and rain that drains in won’t hold your closing chemistry as tightly as a solid cover does.
A mesh winter cover is still a winter cover. Water going through the fabric does not make it a safety cover. If it isn’t built, tested, and anchored as an ASTM F1346 safety cover, it isn’t one.
MIDWINTER · WATER, LEAVES, WIND, ICE
The cover pump earns its keep. The pool stays full enough to hold the cover up.
Two different waters, two different jobs. The water in the pool supports the cover from below. The water on top of a solid cover is the one you pump off.
DON’T DRAIN THE POOL TO HOLD THE COVER
The water underneath is the furniture.
Manufacturer install guides are blunt: the cover rests on, and is supported by, the pool water. If you drain the pool to try to make the cover “sit better,” you’re taking away the thing that’s holding it up. Follow the water-level instructions that came with the pool and the cover. Pump the puddle off the top. Leave the pool itself where it’s supposed to be, and make sure it isn’t quietly leaking out from under the cover all winter.
COVER PUMP
Saves the day. Use it.
After rain or a Tulsa snowmelt, get the standing water off a solid cover as soon as you reasonably can. Cover makers warn that a child can drown in water on top of a winter cover, and that a heavy load can wreck the cover. Check the pump in rainy weather. After a windy night, make sure it’s still upright and the cord didn’t get dragged onto the cover. Use a GFCI-protected outlet, run the discharge well off the cover and away from the pool, and never plug or unplug it while you’re standing in a puddle.
LEAVES
Let them dry. Then evict them.
Leaves are easier when they’re dry. A soft brush or a leaf blower is the usual eviction notice. Do not rake them off with a sharp rake or anything that can punch the fabric. On mesh, water draining through can “steep” a pile of wet leaves into the pool, so don’t let that compost project sit.
WIND, SNOW, AND ICE
Check the cable. Don’t start a fight with ice.
After a windy day, check that the cable is still tight, the clips are still clipped, and the pillow is still in the middle. If ice forms on the cover, don’t chip it, stab it, or try to peel it off. Leave it until it melts, then pump the water off. Heavy snow adds weight; follow the cover maker, and don’t turn snow removal into an ice-chopping project.
COMMON MISTAKES
The hits we see every fall. You can skip the encore.
THE WRONG SIZE, OR THE WRONG SHAPE
Ordering by the printed cover size instead of the pool size. Putting a round cover on an oval. Stretching a too-small cover instead of letting it hug the wall and rest on the water. That’s how covers tear.
A LOOSE CABLE, OR NO CABLE
Wind under a billowing cover is how a lot of good covers die young. Clips and bags help. They do not replace a snug cable and winch. Check it midwinter.
DRAINING THE POOL TO “HOLD” THE COVER
The water in the pool is what supports the cover. Drain it too far and the cover hangs, stretches, and fails. Pump the water off the top, not out of the pool underneath.
MILK JUGS, BRICKS, AND FENCE TIES
Don’t hang jugs, bricks, boards, or other weights from the grommets, and don’t tie the cover off to a fence. Use the cable, clips, and the water bags made for the job. Sharp edges that didn’t get padded will find you later.
A STUFFED PILLOW, OR A WANDERING ONE
Fill it all the way and it has no room to absorb ice. Tie the ropes too tight and the grommets tear. Leave it loose in the middle with no ties and it will not stay in the middle.
LEAVING A LAKE ON TOP — OR CHIPPING THE ICE
Standing water on a solid cover is heavy and hazardous. Pump it off after rain or melt. If it’s ice, wait. And keep kids and pets off every cover, every time. A winter cover will not support weight, no matter how confident the dog looks.
SPRING REMOVAL, CLEANING, DRYING, STORING
Pump it off. Don’t drag it. Put it to bed clean and dry.
Opening day is more fun when the cover comes off in one piece and goes into the shed without a science experiment attached to it.
Get the water off a solid cover first. Pump or siphon off the standing water before you unfasten anything. Trying to drag a cover with a pond on it is how you dump that pond into the pool you just spent all winter protecting.
Loosen the winch, then lift. Release the cable tension the way the winch instructions say — usually a slight tighten, then hold the ratchet lock and let it unwind. Take off the clips and bags. Pull the cover off without dragging it over every sharp cap you forgot to pad in October.
Clean it, then dry it. Hose it off. A little mild detergent and a soft brush are fine. No sharp rakes, and skip the high-pressure-washer heroics unless your cover maker says otherwise. Let it dry thoroughly before it goes into storage. A wet cover in a bag is a mildew starter kit.
Store it cool and dry, and inspect it. Look for wear, crispy fabric, and blown grommets before you pack it, and again before it goes back on next fall. Same once-over for the air pillow: clean, dry, cool storage, away from sharp friends in the box. Some cover makers even suggest a dusting of talcum if your shed runs damp.
At opening, a little silt on the floor after a mesh winter cover is normal. Vacuum to waste and start the usual opening chemistry. For the rest of the spring wakeup, that’s a different class. Or just come see us.
SAFETY COVERS · THE SHORTER, STILL-CLEAR VERSION
If you want a cover that’s actually a barrier. That’s a different product.
A safety cover is not a winter tarp with better manners. It’s a barrier, and it has to earn that name.
WHAT IT IS
ASTM F1346, fastened for real.
When a safety cover is correctly installed and used per the manufacturer, ASTM F1346 (current edition F1346-23) is intended to reduce drowning risk by inhibiting access of children under five. There are manual safety covers you strap to deck anchors, and power safety covers with a motorized mechanism. CPSC’s pool-barrier guidelines specifically mention power safety covers that conform to ASTM F1346 as a security barrier layer. For a lot of the pools we sell, the more common safety-cover path is a custom-fit manual cover that anchors into a deck — if your yard actually has a deck that can take those anchors.
MESH OR SOLID, STILL A SAFETY COVER
The weave is a choice. The standard is the point.
Mesh is the most common type of safety cover: rain drains through, large debris stays out, and a little silt may show up at opening. A solid safety cover blocks sunlight and debris, and it needs a working cover pump or drain panels so standing water doesn’t sit on top. Without a working way to drain, a solid safety cover is not meeting the standard. Either way, kids and pets stay off it as a playground, and it still does not replace a fence or a grown-up who is watching.
No surrounding deck, usually no safety cover. If a deck completely surrounds the pool and can take anchors, a custom safety cover can be an option on some above-ground and semi-in-ground pools. That’s a measure-the-yard conversation. No deck, or only a skinny ribbon of one, and you’re in winter-cover territory — plus a real barrier and real supervision. CPSC says above-ground pools should have barriers too: the pool wall can count if it’s high enough, or you can add a barrier on top, and steps or ladders should be secured, locked, or removed. A winter cover does not check that box.
WHICH ONE IS RIGHT FOR YOU
A very short personality test. Most of you are in the first card.
“I HAVE AN ABOVE-GROUND POOL AND I WANT IT TUCKED IN.”
A good winter cover, sized right, put on tight.
Match the shape. Follow the sizing chart. Add an air pillow, a snug cable and winch, clips or wall bags if the yard is windy, and a cover pump if the cover is solid. Check it after the wind blows. Still not a safety device.
“I WANT A COVER THAT’S ACTUALLY A SAFETY LAYER.”
An ASTM F1346 safety cover — if the yard can take one.
Mesh or solid, measured and anchored to a deck, used the way the manufacturer says. If there isn’t a surrounding deck to anchor to, this is not the cover you can wish onto the pool. We’ll tell you honestly if your yard qualifies.
“WE’VE GOT KIDS OR PETS.”
This is not a winter-cover question.
If the pool can take a safety cover, that’s the cover conversation to have. Add the fence, the gate that actually latches, and a human who is watching. A winter cover does not answer this. Nothing on this page replaces supervision.
“JUST TELL ME THE ONE THING.”
Leaves out. Kids off. Water on the pool, not in a lake on top.
Size it from the chart, fasten it like you mean it, keep the pool water where it can support the cover, and pump the standing water off a solid one. Then keep everyone off it. Come see us if you want a second set of eyes on the yard.
Winter pool cover installation guide hosted by Doughboy (same above-ground cable-and-winch instructions used by cover makers): prepare the pool first; lower water slightly below the skimmer unless a skimmer cover plate is used; ice-equalizer pillow ½ to ¾ full, secured in the middle; pad sharp edges; cover rests on the water with even overhang, draped over the pillow; lace the cable through the grommets and tighten the winch so wind cannot billow under the cover; check cable tension through the winter; remove excess water from a solid cover (mesh drains through); if ice forms, do not tamper with it; siphon standing water before removing a solid cover; store clean and dry in a cool, dry area; walk-around decks may use water tubes, partial decks a mix of tubes and clips.
Robelle Industries above-ground winter-cover installation and care instructions (including the 20-year warranty packet at robelleind.com) and Robelle’s above-ground pool-closing guidance: warning that a winter cover is not a safety cover, will not support weight, and that standing water should be removed because a child can drown on top of the cover; pillow inflated about ¾ full, tied at the center with lines loose enough to float up and down; pool water should not be less than 6 inches from the top of the pool when that maker’s cover goes on; cable snug under the top rails; do not hang bottles or other objects from grommets or tie the cover off to other structures (voids the warranty); pump or siphon water off the cover after rain or snowmelt; wider top rails (that maker cites 7 inches or larger) may need a larger cover size; mesh winter covers use an open weave that keeps debris on top and lets water through.
Arctic Blue Covers sizing guide — order by pool size, not the larger cover size you receive; the cover is made larger than the pool (this maker adds 2 feet) so it extends past the wall; examples for round and oval; top rails take up some of the overhang; if you’re between sizes, keep enough extra material to cover the rails.
GLI Pool Products winter cover owner’s instructions: the cover rests upon and is supported by the pool water, so the pool should not be leaking; pad sharp edges and the underside of the winch; weave the cable through the grommets and tighten the winch, straightening bunched fabric as you go; do not use bricks, boards, milk jugs, or other weights on the grommets; do not rake debris off with a sharp object; do not allow water, snow, or ice to accumulate on the cover; pump all water off before removing the cover; clean with water (mild detergent if needed) and a soft brush, dry thoroughly to prevent mildew, and store properly.
Blue Wave / Arctic Armor (Family Pool Fun) above-ground winter-cover instructions: cover rests on the water; should hug the sidewall and lie on the water — stretching it damages the cover; sized for a maximum water drop (that maker: about 12 inches below the deck); not a safety cover; stay off it; never allow unsupervised children near the pool, covered or uncovered; do not use bricks, milk jugs, or other hold-downs not made for the cover.
Aqua EZ winter-cover instructions: the cover rests upon and is supported by the pool water and should come up the side walls at a right angle with the water level; this maker’s cover is sized larger than the pool to allow for a lower water level; not designed as a safety cover and not designed to support people or any weight; do not stand, walk, crawl, sit, or jump on it. (This maker also says a little water on top can help in the wind. We follow the more common “remove standing water” warning printed on winter covers, plus manufacturer pumping guidance, and we still tell you to follow your own cover’s label.)
Air-pillow manufacturer instructions, including a published user manual and an above-ground pillow sizing chart: inflate to about 60–70% (two-thirds) or ½ to ¾, not full; place in the center and tie so it stays put, with enough slack to move; cover should embrace the pillow and rest on the water around it; size the pillow to the pool, and larger or odd-shaped pools may need more than one; not a toy or a flotation device and not a substitute for adult supervision.
Cover-clip and wall-bag manufacturer guidance (including Swimline cover-clip directions and wall-bag instructions): clips clamp the cover to the outside of the top rail and are used with the cable-and-winch system, typically on both sides of the uprights, with more in high wind; wall bags sit on top of the cover around the inside perimeter, fasten to the cable, and are filled after the cable is tight, about half to three-quarters full; do not use plastic jugs.
Cover-pump manufacturer instructions: automatic pumps typically turn on in a couple of inches of water; check the pump in rainy weather and after high wind so it stays upright and the cord isn’t pulled onto the cover; use a grounded, GFCI-protected outlet; don’t handle the plug while standing in water.
ASTM F1346-23 official scope; ANSI Blog summary of the F1346-23 tests (static load, perimeter deflection, surface drainage, openings); F1346-91 (2003) classification language for power safety covers, manual safety covers, and “other covers,” including debris covers, which “are not intended to serve as a barrier for children under the age of five.” The current edition is F1346-23; CPSC’s barrier guidelines still cite F1346-91.
CPSC Publication 362, Safety Barrier Guidelines for Residential Pools — barriers include a fence or wall, door alarms, and a power safety cover; barriers are not childproof and can never replace adult supervision; the guidelines are not a CPSC standard and are not mandatory by themselves; pool covers should be well maintained; power safety covers should conform to ASTM F 1346-91; above-ground pools should have barriers, and steps or ladders should be secured, locked, or removed.
Merlin Industries Safety Cover Owner’s Guide — used only in the shorter safety-cover section: mesh vs. solid safety covers; a solid safety cover needs a working pump or drain panel; nothing replaces proper supervision; walking on a safety cover is not recommended as a habit; a surrounding deck and proper anchors matter.
NWS Tulsa frost/freeze climatology — mean first 32°F freeze in fall is November 3; mean last 32°F freeze in spring is March 29 (period January 1906 through May 2026).
Sources checked November 15, 2026 (America/Chicago). Ryan portrait supplied by The Fin, from the approved-bio set (library, flamingo float, skimmer net). Pull quote authored for this page. No prices or retailer-lineup claims included. This page is Pool School education, not a substitute for your cover’s instructions, your pump’s manual, or local barrier codes. ASTM F1346 is a copyrighted standard; we used the official abstract, a public ANSI summary of the tests, and the publicly circulated F1346-91 (2003) classification language, and we did not reproduce the standard. Overlap amounts, exact water-drop limits, and pillow sizes vary by maker, so this page tells you to use the chart that comes with the product rather than treating any one brand’s numbers as universal.
Wondering which cover your above-ground pool should wear this winter?