The Fin pool, spa & hot tubs, Tulsa OK The Fin Get a quote

POOL CHEMISTRY · LEARNING WITH THE FIN

Chlorine. The OG germ bouncer.

Simply put, chlorine is the easiest way to kill bacteria. It has been the standard in pool sanitation for ages, which is why most pool sanitizing systems (yes, even the fancy ones) use chlorine in some shape or form. Tablets, granular, liquid, salt… it’s a lot. So grab a floatie and let’s wade in, one splash at a time.

Ryan Musch of The Fin standing by a backyard pool in a black suit and tie with sunglasses, swim goggles around his neck, orange arm floaties and a googly-eyed fish floatie, holding a pool brush pole, owner of The Fin in Tulsa
By Ryan Musch Director of Liquid Affairs, The Fin Germs, you’ve been warned 🦠

“Simply put, chlorine kills bacteria.”

Ryan, Director of Liquid Affairs (and bacteria’s least favorite person)

① WHAT IS CHLORINE?

You already know it. You just didn’t know you knew it.

Chlorine is everywhere. A lot of household cleaning products have chlorine in them, and even the tap water you drink is chlorinated. So when it comes to pools, it’s less “new kid” and more “the friend who’s been here the whole time.”

How it works

Chlorine keeps a pool clean through a series of chemical reactions. It breaks down the cells of harmful bacteria and renders them harmless. Buh-bye, bacteria.

The bleach question

Think of bleach. Most household bleach is chlorine-based (some “oxygen” bleaches use hydrogen peroxide instead). Technically, you can sanitize a pool with bleach, but it costs a lot more than buying the real pool stuff, like granular or chlorine tablets.

💸

Cheap first date. Pricey relationship.

Chlorine is typically the cheapest way to sanitize upfront, but season by season it can add up to one of the most expensive. Especially if you let your chlorine levels drop and the pool turns green. (Green is a great color for frogs. Less so for pools.)

On the bright side, some folks like spreading the cost of pool care out over time, and that works for a lot of budgets.

A traditional chlorine system works by adding chlorine to the pool as needed, typically about once a week. You’ve got three ways to do it:

  • 💊 Chlorine tablets
  • 🪣 Granular chlorine
  • 🧃 Liquid chlorine
Clear turquoise pool water with a stainless steel pool ladder at the edge

② TABLETS, GRANULAR OR LIQUID?

Three ways to chlorinate. Pick your potion.

Same germ-fighting goal, three very different personalities. Here’s who you’d be bringing home.

01

Tablets. Slow and steady.

The steady Eddie

Chlorine tablets dissolve slowly, so they give you a more stable chlorine level that doesn’t peak and valley so much over time. No big spike when you add them; they just keep chugging along.

Tablets are usually fed through a chlorine dispenser called a chlorinator. These are very inexpensive for the average DIY homeowner to buy, install and service.

  • 👍Steady, low-drama chlorine levels
  • 👀Tablets have a lower pH than you keep your pool at, so you’ll adjust pH a little more often than with granular alone. Not that bad, though.
02

Granular. The bucket brigade.

Hands-on, a little high-maintenance

Granular is a little harder to use than the others. Dissolve it in a bucket of water, then pour it around the edge of the pool, preferably over the return jets.

Your chlorine level spikes, stays high for a while, drifts down, and then you add more when it gets low. Repeat. It’s a roller coaster, minus the fun.

  • ⚠️On its own, it’s a lot easier for the pool to turn green or build up bacteria (hello, cloudy water), because it depends on you adding chlorine whenever the level gets low, which isn’t always the same day every week.
  • 🌧️Levels don’t always drop at the same rate. A few extra swimmers, a rain, or a few extra-hot days can burn through your usual dose faster.
  • 🤝Most commonly, granular is used with tablets: smaller amounts, a little less often, usually just to “shock” the pool and knock out bacteria the steady tablet level isn’t keeping up with.
03

Liquid. Pour and go.

Easy pour, needs a big closet

Liquid chlorine is popular because you pour it straight into the pool. No mixing. The catch? It’s already dissolved, so it takes up a lot of room.

8–16+ weeks vs. a week or twoTwo buckets hold 8–16 weeks or more of tablets and granular, but only a week or two of liquid.
25 lbs vs. 25 gallonsOne gallon of liquid is roughly a pound or so of granular, depending on brand and strength. That usually means a huge storage barrel or a lot of trips to the pool store.
  • 🧯It has a really high pH and is very corrosive, so plan on keeping acid around and adding it regularly to bring pH back down.
A floating chlorine dispenser bobbing in a pool next to a rubber duck wearing sunglasses

CHLORINATORS COME IN TWO STYLES

Plumbed-in or floatie?

  • Automatic: added to, or tied directly into, your pool’s plumbing and filtration system. Adjustable.
  • Floating: a simpler dispenser that bobs around the pool (sunglasses-wearing duck optional).

THE SET-IT ROUTINE

Keep it stocked. Keep it running.

  1. Keep tablets in the chlorinator.
  2. Run the filter system on a schedule.
  3. Set the chlorinator dial to the level you need.

Result: a constant level of chlorine in your pool. 🎉

POOL MATH (WE PROMISE IT’S SHORT)

CC = TC − FC

Combined chlorine = total chlorine − free chlorine. With tablets doing the steady work, you only need to shock occasionally: after a pool party 🎈, or if your free chlorine test reads lower than your combined chlorine.

③ THE BENEFITS OF A TRADITIONAL CHLORINE SYSTEM

The good stuff. Why it’s a classic.

Keep an eye on your levels, add chlorine as needed, and your pool should stay crystal clear.

Low-cost setup

The system itself is a low-cost investment.

Easy to use

Chlorine is very easy to add to a pool. No engineering degree required.

Barely any equipment fuss

Traditional chlorine systems need extremely little equipment maintenance.

Help is easy to find

Because these systems are so widely used, they’re the easiest type to find someone to work on or repair if issues come up.

Real talk on price: the biggest perk used to be that both the system and the chlorine were inexpensive. With recent price increases, the chlorine itself is now fairly expensive. The low system cost and ease of use are still big wins, though.

③ THE DRAWBACKS OF A TRADITIONAL CHLORINE SYSTEM

The not-so-good. Hold your nose.

  1. 01

    That “swimming pool smell”

    Anyone who spent their childhood at the public pool remembers it. That’s pretty much all chloramine, the byproduct of chlorine reacting with bacteria in the pool. For some people, the smell alone is reason enough to choose another system.

  2. 02

    Eyes, skin, hair & clothes

    Add in irritation on eyes and skin, plus harshness on hair and swimsuits, and traditional chlorine can get knocked out of the running for some swimmers.

  3. The big one03

    It doesn’t self-regulate

    Chlorine pools are generally the least expensive sanitizing option, but they also need the most maintenance labor. You are the autopilot. Sorry.

  4. 04

    pH can make or break it

    Chlorine loses much of its effectiveness when your pH drifts too far off, so expect to spend more time adding other chemicals to keep your chlorine working.

  5. 05

    The sun is a chlorine thief

    Without a chlorine stabilizer such as cyanuric acid, sunlight will burn through your chlorine fairly quickly. Sunscreen for your sanitizer, basically.

  6. 06

    Handle with care

    Chlorine is a dangerous chemical. It’s generally fine once diluted in a pool, but in its pure chemical or tablet form it can be hazardous if not stored and handled responsibly.

④ CHLORINE vs. SALTWATER CHLORINATOR

Same chlorine. Different delivery guy.

The main difference between these two is how the chlorine gets into the water. A saltwater chlorinator makes its own chlorine from dissolved salt using a process called electrolysis. A regular chlorine pool needs you to add liquid, powder or tablet chlorine yourself.

Plot twist: both systems use the same chemical form of chlorine to clean and sanitize the water. Salt pools aren’t chlorine-free; they just brew their own. 🧂⚡

THE MATCHUP Regular chlorine 🪣You do the pouring Saltwater chlorinator 🧂The pool makes its own
HOW THEY WORK

REGULAR CHLORINEYou physically pour or drop chlorine chemicals into the pool on a regular schedule.

SALTWATER CHLORINATORA salt chlorine generator (also called a salt cell) is wired to the pump system. Water with dissolved pool salt passes over charged metal plates that turn the salt into active sanitizing chlorine.

MAINTENANCE

REGULAR CHLORINENeeds hands-on testing every week or two, plus a steady stream of chemical purchases.

SALTWATER CHLORINATORAutomates daily sanitizing, so you get fewer chemical spikes and less frequent manual testing. The salt cell needs an occasional cleaning and replacing every 3 to 7 years.

COST

REGULAR CHLORINELower setup cost, but higher long-term chemical expenses.

SALTWATER CHLORINATORHigher setup cost for the equipment, but cheaper ongoing chemical upkeep.

COMFORT

REGULAR CHLORINEIf the water isn’t balanced right, you can get strong chloramine smells and eye or skin irritation.

SALTWATER CHLORINATORWater feels softer and doesn’t have those harsh chemical odors.

A yellow rubber duck floating in a clear blue backyard pool next to a ladder

THE BOTTOM LINE

Which one wins? It depends.

There are quite a few pool sanitizing systems out there. The most popular are these three:

  • 🪣 Traditional chlorine
  • 🧂 Saltwater
  • 💎 Mineral

If there were one perfect pool sanitizing system, there wouldn’t be so many to choose from. Like most things about building a pool, saltwater, chlorine and mineral systems each have their own pros and cons. The right one for you? It depends what you value most.

Swimcerely, Ryan

KEEP LEARNING

More from Pool School.

⑤ FREE WATER TESTING

Not sure what your water is up to?

Bring us a water sample from your pool or hot tub and we’ll test it for FREE. Then we’ll help you figure out what your water actually needs, whether you’re team tablets, team liquid, or still deciding.

Stock photos via Unsplash: Lee Jeffs, Thom Milkovic, Mike Szczepanski, engin akyurt, Debby Hudson.